Potion Shop Simulator Review: Charming But Sluggish Shopkeeping

Potion Shop Simulator Review: Charming But Sluggish Shopkeeping

By Marcus Chen

March 19, 2025 at 03:09 PM

Potion Shop Simulator transports players into a fantasy world where they manage a mysterious potion shop after its previous owner's disappearance. While the game offers a charming atmosphere, it struggles to find the right balance between relaxation and engagement.

Screenshot of potion shop game interface

Screenshot of potion shop game interface

Key Features:

  • Ingredient gathering and processing
  • Potion crafting system
  • Shop management
  • Greenhouse cultivation
  • Gradual upgrade progression

Magical interior of fantasy potion store

Magical interior of fantasy potion store

Strengths:

  • Immersive fantasy world
  • Calming atmosphere
  • Detailed crafting mechanics
  • Quality-of-life upgrades

Green monster in potion shop

Green monster in potion shop

Areas for Improvement:

  • Slow, repetitive gameplay loop
  • Limited customer interaction variety
  • Basic potion crafting system
  • Underwhelming upgrade rewards
  • Tedious early-game progression

The game excels in creating a cozy atmosphere but needs refinement in its core mechanics. The addition of customer personalities, meaningful recipe development, and more impactful upgrades would significantly enhance the experience.

Currently available on PC via Steam.

GameTyrant review score: 6/10

GameTyrant review score: 6/10

Dining room with bright red tables

Dining room with bright red tables

Excavated hole in residential lawn

Excavated hole in residential lawn

image

image

Crowned skull on stone pedestal

Crowned skull on stone pedestal

Vintage car driving through rain

Vintage car driving through rain

Medieval tavern interior with wooden bar

Medieval tavern interior with wooden bar

Previous Articles